document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", function() { })

Is it really a bad idea to list a home during the holidays? Do leads go cold after 30 days? And are your best agents destined to leave your team? In this episode of the Reside Platform Podcast, Brooke Riecke and Karlton Utter challenge six common real estate beliefs and share what team leaders can do differently. They talk about using local market data to guide sellers, nurturing older leads with relevant opportunities, creating meaningful growth paths for top performers, and building the systems and support a team needs to scale. They also discuss how to approach owners selling on their own and why a slower market can be a chance to strengthen your leadership, recruiting, and business. If your team is navigating a shift, this conversation offers practical ways to keep moving forward.

Chapters:

  • (00:00:00) Real estate myths team leaders hear every day
  • (00:07:00) Why older real estate leads deserve a follow up
  • (00:13:00) How to reconnect with leads and offer real value
  • (00:18:00) Why top producing agents stay on a team
  • (00:24:00) Scaling beyond a leader’s capacity
  • (00:29:00) How to approach owners selling their own homes
  • (00:33:00) Growing a real estate team in a slow market
  • (00:39:00) Adapting your strategy as the market shifts
  • (00:45:00) Leadership actions for the week ahead

Links and Resources:

Thanks so much for joining us this week. Want to subscribe to the Reside Platform Podcast? Have some feedback you’d like to share? Connect with us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube to leave us a review!

KEY QUESTIONS ANSWERED — 

Read More

Q: Is it a bad idea to list a home during the holidays?

A: No. Karlton and Brooke call this a myth. People still need to buy and sell year-round, and the buyers who come out in November and December are serious. There is also less inventory, which means less competition for the listing.

Q: How should agents handle sellers who want to wait until spring?

A: Pull the local data and show the seller what inventory and pricing actually look like. Brooke suggests taking listing photos now while the weather is nice, signing the listing agreement, and setting a later on-market date, after checking your state rules.

Q: Do real estate leads go cold after 30 days?

A: No. Karlton says most people are seven to fourteen months away from buying when an agent first connects with them. Most conversions come from leads that are 30 or more days old, so they need a long-term nurture plan.

Q: How should agents follow up with older leads?

A: Skip “not sure if you remember me” and “just checking in.” Assume they remember you, reference where you met, and lead with a specific property that fits what they wanted. The goal of the call is to book an appointment, not to pre-qualify them over the phone.

Q: How can agents use showings to reconnect with their database?

A: After showing four or five homes, go back to your CRM and find three to five people who would fit each property. Call them about the home you were just in, because you can speak about it with real excitement.

Q: Will high-performing agents eventually leave a real estate team?

A: Not if the team keeps delivering value. Top agents stay for the leadership, culture, and growth opportunities. The risk is when a leader pulls back support once an agent starts producing. Regular one-on-one conversations about the agent’s future on the team keep everyone aligned.

Q: Can a real estate team scale past the leader’s capacity?

A: Karlton says yes, as long as the leader finds people who complement their weaknesses. Brooke says it depends: without leverage, systems, and processes, the team will hit a wall at whatever the leader can personally handle.

Q: Do for sale by owner sellers really not want to work with an agent?

A: Many FSBO sellers have been trying for months and are getting frustrated. Karlton cites NAR data showing only about 20 percent succeed on their own, and roughly half of those sell to friends, family, or acquaintances. A simple script asking to preview the home and when they would consider listing usually gets the agent in the door.

Q: Is a slow market a bad time to grow a real estate team?

A: Brooke and Karlton both say it is the best time. Leaders have more time to fix their recruiting process, and many agents are lost and looking for leadership. Karlton grew his 85-agent office during the 2006 and 2007 downturn while competitors folded.

Q: What should team leaders do in a shifting market?

A: Lead. Agents need direction, accountability, and optimism. Karlton’s first manager told him to know his numbers, from each agent’s production to market trends, so he could get ahead of shifts instead of reacting to them.


THE TRANSCRIPT — 

Read More

Everyone knows that you should never list a house during the holidays. Everyone knows leads go cold after thirty days. Everyone knows expired listings are easy money. But is that actually true? Today we’re finding out how much of what everyone knows is actually true in real estate. Welcome back to the Reside Platform Podcast. I’m Brooke Riecke, and I’m here with Karlton Utter. Today’s episode is going to be a fun one. We’re doing Mythbusters, real estate edition. We each brought some myths that we hear from agents and team leaders all the time, and we’re going to call them out: true, myth, or somewhere in between depending on the situation. One of us will read the myth, the other gives their verdict, and we’ll end each one with something the team can actually do this week. Karlton, how does that sound?

That sounds awesome. I’m ready to do some myth busting. Let’s go.

I’ll start with one I’m hearing very commonly right now. Everyone knows that you should never list a house during the holidays. What are your thoughts?

Look, people need to sell and people need to buy throughout the entire year. Is it a traditional time to put a home on the market? Typically not. Most people don’t want to be decorating for the holidays and having parties while their home is on the market. And in a lot of markets it starts to get colder, with ice and snow coming in. But if you need to sell, put your home on the market. It’s a great time to target buyers who are serious about purchasing. You’re not getting the looky-loos. Nobody is coming out in the cold November rain right before Thanksgiving to get decorating tips. You’re getting folks who want to buy. It’s not your spring market, when everybody comes on. But when everybody else comes on, why would you want to come on at the same time? If you have some flexibility and don’t need to time your closing around summer and getting kids into a new school, it’s a great time to put the home on the market.

I totally agree. What’s your verdict? Would you say it’s a myth?

I think it’s a myth. I don’t think there’s a right or wrong time. Is there a more traditional time when we tend to see more people sell? Yes. But supply and demand dictates values at any given time. Interest rates go up and down. Just because they’re a little higher right now doesn’t make this a bad time to list. In another month those rates could be below where they are now, and you have less competition. There are so many variables that there’s really not a right or wrong time.

I’d agree, for the exact same reasons. Traditionally you hear about the spring market, but transactions are always going to happen. There are always going to be life events you can’t control: death, divorce, marriage, and kids. Those are always factors. And less inventory means less competition. The buyers in November and December are really serious, because no one wants to look at a bunch of homes in the cold unless they’re ready to move forward.

We’re seeing a lot more people put their home on the market heading into the fall and the back end of the year than we’ve seen in quite a while, which proves the myth doesn’t hold. It comes down to presenting all the facts to your seller. If you know your numbers and you’re a true neighborhood expert, you can give good, sound advice. And if the seller has specific needs and doesn’t feel it’s the right time, it’s not fair to push them just because you want inventory. We don’t have a crystal ball. Our job is to present the facts and let them decide.

Absolutely. It’s not on us to convince them to list now. But it is good to prepare for that conversation, because you will start hearing the objection, “We’re going to wait until spring.” Dig deeper into what that means. Is it just tradition, or does the data say it really doesn’t matter? Pull that data. You might be surprised by what inventory typically looks like and how well homes still sell. And if they’re worried about photos, I’ve been telling agents and teams: if we know we’re listing in the next six months, let’s get photos now while it’s still pretty outside. You can get the listing agreement signed and set the on-market date later. Check your state laws on how long you have between signing and getting it into the MLS. It’s a great way to handle that objection as we get into the season.

Next one. Everyone knows that leads go cold after thirty days. I know what you’re going to say on this, Karlton, so I’m excited to hear it.

I just did a webinar yesterday and talked about some of these stats. The scary part is that most leads don’t get a single follow-up attempt after one or two tries. We have this need for instant gratification. We want the leads that are ready to buy this weekend with a briefcase full of cash. The reality is that most folks are seven to fourteen months out from making a purchase when we connect with them. That doesn’t mean they won’t buy sooner. It’s up to us to create some motivation, give them the knowledge to make an educated decision, and help get them financially ready. It’s a large purchase. Same with listing leads. Sellers need time to get the home ready. So it’s a shame when we give up on folks within thirty days.

My approach is: you’re either going to buy or sell with me, or you’re going to call me and say take me off your list. Agents need to get out of the “I don’t want to bother them” mindset. You’re not bothering them. You’re marketing yourself and staying in front of them. If you’re not doing it, they’ll meet another realtor who does, and you’ll finally get them on the phone and hear, “Oh, we bought a home six months ago.” Then you look at your CRM and realize you haven’t followed up in eight months. When people tell you they’re going to hold off, set up a strong cultivation program. Send emails full of value and text messages. Don’t just check in. Say, “I wanted to let you know about this awesome property. Here’s a photo.” Make the phone calls. Heading into the holidays is a great time to reach out to everyone, wish them a happy holiday, and ask if they’re still thinking about buying or selling and what their timeframe looks like. Too many folks give up and chase the next lead. There’s gold in that pipeline. Every hundred people in your database is a minimum of one transaction. Add them to your database and set up a long-term cultivation program.

To be completely transparent, this one makes me irrationally angry. It’s so common for agents to get a new lead source and say it doesn’t work. “I called them twice, sent a text, sent an email, and I tried.” Okay, how long has it been? With certain lead sources, the more you convert, the better the leads get. You have to give it time to let the system work. You might have a great attack plan for the first seven or ten days. But what happens after that? No one really talks about leads that are thirty-plus days old, and that’s probably where most of your conversions will come from. Think about any big decision in your life. It doesn’t happen instantly. Buying a home is one of the biggest decisions someone will make, so treat it that way and nurture them with value. Not “Are you ready to sell?” over and over, but “Here’s when it makes sense for you to sell based on your market.” If you take one thing from this, pull a list of leads in your CRM that are sixty to one hundred eighty days old, give each one a personal outreach, and make sure you have a follow-up plan.

I want to add something. When you call these folks, please do not say, “Not sure if you remember me,” or “I’m just checking in.” Whether they remember you or not, they had an interest in buying or selling, and they’re going to need a realtor at some point. You need to be there along the way. Assume they remember who you are and get right into it. “I met you a month ago at the open house at 123 Main Street. You mentioned you liked the home, and it’s still available. I’d like to get you back in. Plus, one just came on at 153 Main Street, a couple of blocks down. Very similar home, same price point, beautiful house.” Don’t get into “Are you still looking? Did you ever get pre-approved?” Stop trying to pre-qualify people and go for the appointment. Challenge yourself to book appointments, not to have twenty-minute conversations that don’t end in one.

Absolutely. And that’s providing value. You showed interest in this property, and I have another one you’ll probably enjoy, so let’s meet there. You can dive into qualifying once you’re together.

Every time you go out with buyers, I don’t like to show more than four or five homes, because after that nobody remembers the first couple. Whichever one they decide to buy comes off the list. Now you’ve got four properties you saw that day. Go back to your database, look at everyone in your notes who’s over thirty days, and call three to five people about each home you just showed. You were just inside it, so you can speak about it passionately and build some motivation and excitement.

I want to get into some team-specific ones, because these felt a little spicier. Everyone knows that a high-performing agent will eventually leave the team. You get them to high producing, and they leave you. What are your thoughts?

I have to bust that myth. I see some of the top producing teams out there, and their top agents don’t have a reason to leave. They’re doing extremely well within that team. They’ve built a phenomenal business, and it works for them. If something is really working for you, why would you change it? I love change, but I don’t change things just for the sake of it. It’s really hard to run a top-performing real estate business. If it works for you within a team, I would not change that up.

Agents at any experience level stay because of the value on the team, the leadership, and the growth opportunities. Where I think this myth comes from is a leader who spent a lot of time with an agent, meeting once a week, and the agent is finally producing and consistent. Then the leader takes their foot off the gas, intentionally or not. They stop meeting because the agent is fine. The agent feels that and wonders what happened to their backbone and what the next step is. So be open and transparent. Especially with the end of the year coming up, have one-on-one conversations with each agent about their future on the team. Top producers become the best mentors, directors of sales, sales managers, and coaches. There’s so much they can grow into that will keep them with you. Keep that communication flowing and keep investing in the team culture.

The term I’d use is alignment. Top teams succeed in sports, in real estate, wherever, because people are aligned and understand what they’re working toward. Heading into the back end of the year, we’re moving into business planning time. It’s a good time for a team leader to make sure everyone understands where we finished this year, what we accomplished, and what we want to accomplish next year as a team. In spring training, every baseball team’s goal is to win the World Series. In football training camp, they’re talking about the Super Bowl. What’s your goal, and what’s everybody’s role in getting there? When I interviewed people about joining a team versus going independent, the ones who chose a team wanted guidance and support. They wanted to work with like-minded professionals and bought into where the team leader was going. A lot of them came from the military, sports, bands, or organizations where you count on other people. I could be a solo musician, but I love being in bands, with all the instruments and harmonies working together. I just like being part of a team.

Even at Reside, working with you guys and with our clients is my favorite part. It all comes back to community, finding your tribe and the people you belong with. That’s a big reason people join teams. But it’s also the team leader’s responsibility to keep everyone aligned. As an agent, you want to align with the values of the team leader. As a team leader, you’re the captain. It’s your job to help get them where they want to be.

Speaking of leaders, here’s another one. Everyone knows a team can’t scale past the leader’s capacity.

I don’t believe that’s true at all. Team leaders all have different experience, personalities, and leadership styles. Some lead by example, some by coaching and training. As a team leader, you have to decide what scaling looks like and what you need to put in place to get there. Some team leaders do a lot of production, some don’t, and some are a hybrid. It’s okay for that role to shift. If you were the rainmaker and now the team is bringing in business too, you can back off from spending eighty hours a week with buyers and sellers and focus on how to grow, support, develop, and lead the team. I tell team leaders all the time: if you know you’re not good at something that will help your team get better, find someone who complements you, either already on the team or someone you bring in. Don’t force a square peg into a round hole. You’ll never be motivated to do something you don’t like, and people feel that. The same is true for agents. If they dread an activity and don’t see the benefit, it’s hard to get them to do it.

I agree with you, but based on everything you just said, I’m going to call it true, actually. What I keep hearing as you talk is leverage, systems, and processes. You can scale past the leader’s capacity, but you need those things. If you’re missing even one of them, you’re going to hit a wall. If the leader can’t leverage out support, or there’s no system for tracking things, no database, or no process for how it all comes together, you’re only going to get so far when everything lives in the leader’s head. That’s just human. So I’d say it’s true to a degree.

I like it.

Let’s do a couple more. Did any of them stand out to you?

You’ve got a couple on here about for sale by owners and expired listings. Look, if you want listings, go call expireds. For our friends in Canada, there are almost no for sale by owners up there. It’s not a common practice. But here in the United States, go into Zillow, filter your market to only for sale by owner, and you’ll be surprised how many there are. Or just drive your neighborhoods and look for signs. These folks want to sell and don’t fully understand the process, and they’re not getting the marketing that gets eyes on the property and feet in the door. Don’t assume everyone else is calling them or that they don’t want a realtor. A lot of them have been trying for months and are getting fed up. Some are testing the waters before they list. Some are seeing which realtors are aggressive enough to reach out. And some will yell at you when you call, and that’s okay.

If you call and say, “I see you’re selling your home on your own. I owe it to myself, my clients, and my business to know all the available inventory. I’d love to come preview the house and hear why you’re selling and what your goals are, so I can talk to clients who might be interested,” that will almost always get you in the door. The other question is, “Do you have a timeframe in mind for when you’d consider listing with a realtor?” Most people plan to try it for a month or two. Some will say never, and that’s fine. You need to know. FSBO sellers are usually trying to save on commission. But NAR stats show for sale by owners only have about a twenty percent success rate selling on their own, and half of those sell to friends, family, and acquaintances. Even when they do sell, they’re missing out on an average of an additional ten thousand dollars in profit they would have earned with a realtor, because they miss the mass marketing.

That one caught my eye for the same reason, and it ties back to the holiday myth. These sellers are listing out of necessity. As we get into the time of year when fewer buyers are out looking, it’s the perfect time to reach out and offer support. Don’t shy away from them.

The one I definitely want to touch on: everybody knows a slow market is the worst time to grow a team.

I’d argue it’s the best time to grow a team. In a slow market, you need more people coming in to do the work, bump up the dials and the conversion, and increase volume. A lot of people take their foot off the gas when it’s slow. This is the time to put your foot all the way down. You may also have extra time you don’t normally have. I’m telling the teams I talk to: great, use that time to triple your activities or close the loops you’ve been meaning to close. If you’ve been meaning to fix your recruiting process, now’s the time. And as everyone else takes their foot off the gas heading into the holidays, be the people who keep going. There’s always a need to buy or sell real estate, so be there for your team and your clients.

Every year around this time, the market slows down. And we’re in a shifting market that’s getting more challenging. A lot of realtors and team leaders haven’t been in a balanced or buyer-focused market since COVID, so they only know one type of market. In a slower, shifting market, team leaders need to embrace the leader part of their job description. Your agents are looking for direction, accountability, support, and guidance so they can keep making the money they need to support their families and pay their mortgages. When you hear an agent say this market is terrible, stop them. Sit down and ask how they’re feeling, what they’re struggling with, and how to work through it. Give them action items, because there’s opportunity in this market. A lot of agents out there are lost and shutting down. It’s not a bad market if you have guidance, leadership, and optimism.

I saw this firsthand. I had an office with eighty-five agents in 2006. At the beginning of 2006, we were doing a hundred transactions a month. It’s easy to lead an office in a good market, because everyone’s happy. It gets tough when the market shifts, and you can’t do what agents sometimes do, which is give up and wait for things to get better. In 2006, we went from three months of inventory to six, to fifteen, to thirty within about a year. It was my job to make sure eighty-five agents were successful. As a team leader, it’s your job to keep your agents excited and motivated and show them where the business can be found. It’s change management. You have different conversations with buyers and sellers in different markets. That’s what I’ve been bringing to the entire Reside network over the past month or two. As a leader, you say: here’s the end game, here’s what we’re going to do, and here’s how we work as a team to get there. When an agent throws their hands up, I say let’s figure this out, because I want you to have the best finish to the year you can and the best 2027 ever. It doesn’t mean you stop doing what you do. It means you work a little differently.

Exactly. The longer you’re in real estate, the more you see these patterns, and you need different strategies for each type of market. COVID was crazy. I also grew up with my dad in real estate my whole life. In 2008, when everything was crashing, he was probably doing his best. He pivoted to working with sellers who couldn’t afford their homes anymore and did pre-foreclosures. At one point he had about sixty listings in one month, helping sellers who were about to lose their homes find something that worked better for them. It’s not the time to throw your hands up. It’s the time to ask what else you can do. Agents, talk to your team leaders. Leaders, talk to your coaches. I love using AI to brainstorm what I could be doing in this kind of market. You might get ideas that are different from what you’re used to, and that’s okay.

This isn’t an industry where you only sell when the market’s good. It’s like being a stockbroker. You can’t control the market, and you have a fiduciary responsibility. We chose this career. Not once have I said I wish I never got into real estate. Even in 2007, when I spent all day every day meeting with sellers about price reductions and watching commissions and home values dwindle, it was an honor and a privilege to be in this industry. If the fire isn’t lit right now, do some soul searching, figure out how to get excited and motivated, and get back out there. It’s about having different conversations and more conversations. You can’t bury your head in the sand. Sometimes you have to say, “Mr. and Mrs. Buyer, we need to have a serious conversation about what’s going on.” Same with sellers. Spend more time researching so you can speak as an expert, because the numbers don’t lie.

When I started managing, I asked a longtime manager named Terry for his one piece of advice. He said, “Know your numbers.” Know your office numbers and your agents’ numbers. Know when they’re having a good month and a bad month, and get ahead of it. More importantly, know the numbers in the market so you can see what’s shifting and build your own predictive analytics. You don’t want to run a reactionary business. Let the agents who don’t know what they’re doing struggle, while your team works through it. That also gives you recruiting opportunities, because you can call the agents who are lost. I grew my office during that downturn while other offices were folding. A lot of discount brokers that had popped up disappeared. It came down to the companies that were financially strong and had leaders optimistic enough to work through it. Coming out of it, we had the team we wanted and were better positioned for the next market. So it’s a hundred percent the right time to find agents who are a little disenchanted, help them stay in the business, and be successful. That connection keeps them with you into the next market.

Unfortunately, we’re coming up on time. This was so fun, and there are so many other myths we’re hearing right now, so hopefully we can come back for a part two. We also want to hear from you. What myths are coming up for you right now? As for the final scorecard, most of what everyone knows turned out to be a myth, or at least half of the story. Karlton, as we wrap up, for those this might be hitting close to home, what’s one action item you’d suggest for this week?

As a team leader, embrace your role as the leader and understand what your agents are going through right now. They need somebody to lead them through this, not somebody who agrees with them or buys into what’s happening in the market. And agents, people are buying and selling real estate. Look at the number of transactions happening in your marketplace. Don’t get caught up in the media. I just saw a news channel post on social media ripping the real estate market and saying how high interest rates are. Historically, rates are in a good place, and they’re always going to go up and down. Buyers have a huge opportunity right now, and sellers still have a great opportunity to sell. Are prices balancing out and dropping a little? Yes, but most sellers still have a lot of equity, and they’ll probably get a really good deal on whatever they buy next. It all works out. Stay in front of everybody in your database and keep having conversations, so when the pent-up demand releases, they want to work with you and not somebody else.

I couldn’t have ended that better myself. You heard it here. For anyone listening, if you have thoughts or questions, please reach out to Karlton and me. These are the conversations we love, and it’s why we do what we do with our teams and agents. Reach out if you need extra support right now. We’re here to help. Thank you all for listening, and we’ll see you next time on the Reside Platform Podcast.


Reside Platform Podcast

Would you like to be a guest on the Reside Platform Podcast? We are always looking for incredible leaders in the real estate space to be a guest on our podcast. We are always focused on bringing forward individuals that can provide value and inspiration for our audience.

The Reside Platform Podcast is from Suneet Agarwal, President & Co-Founder of Reside Platform and author of Team Leader Secrets.